50% Off Additional Pages or up to 45% Off Almost Everything Else Code YAYPAGES Ends: 04/28
Details

The Worst Mother’s Day Gifts (According to Real Moms)

Let’s be real — shopping for Mom can be tough. You want to show you care, but it’s all too easy to fall into the trap of buying what’s convenient, not what’s meaningful.

We asked over 2,500 moms and their kids what gifts hit the mark — and which ones totally miss. Here's what they had to say.

If you were thinking of giving your mom a vacuum or a low-carb protein powder this Mother’s Day… you might want to reconsider.

First Things First: What Moms Actually Want

Before you grab that “World’s Best Mom” mug (again), take a beat. What moms really want is to feel seen and appreciated.

Hint: The #1 thing they mentioned? Thoughtful, personalized gifts — like a custom Mixbook photo book. Something made just for her, filled with memories that matter.

The Top 8 Worst Mother’s Day Gifts (Yes, Really)

1. Weight Loss Products (30%)

– Please don’t. It’s not inspiring. It’s insulting.

2. Cleaning Supplies (26%)

– Nothing says “I appreciate you” like a new mop… said no mom ever.

3. “How to Cook” Cookbooks (14%)

– You’re basically saying her cooking could use work.

4. Unsolicited Self-Help Books (12%)

– Unless she asked for it, skip it.

5. Leftover Holiday Chocolates (7%)

– If it still says “Happy Valentine’s Day,” it’s a hard pass.

6. Gas Station Flowers (5%)

– She deserves better than wilted daisies and windshield wipes.

7. Homemade Coupon Books (3%)

– Cute when you’re 6. Less so at 36.

8. Gift Cards… to Stores YOU Like (2%)

– If it’s not for her, it’s not a gift.

“Over half of moms admitted someone forgot Mother’s Day at least once.” — Mixbook Survey, 2024

Last-Minute Givers, You're Not Alone

52% of respondents said they’ve forgotten Mother's Day before. Here’s how they scrambled to make it right:

  • 35% gave cash (a decent backup)
  • 31% offered a big hug
  • 19% made a long, heartfelt phone call
  • 16% created handmade IOU cards

You can do better. A personalized gift takes just minutes to create and shows you really care.

50% off additional pages or up to 45% off*
Code: YAYPAGES | Ends 4/28!

What Really Works: The Gifts Moms Love Most

Here’s what topped the list of meaningful gifts:

  • 27.5% – Handmade gifts
  • 21% – Special experiences (spa days, brunch, etc.)
  • 16% – Handwritten letters or cards
  • 10% – A day off from responsibilities

It’s clear: a heartfelt gesture goes way further than something expensive or generic.

Bottom Line: Show You *Really* Know Her

Mother’s Day isn’t about flashy gifts — it’s about feeling loved. This year, skip the mop and make something that matters.

Get it in time to wow Mom

Lay flats, home decor, and foil cards

Apr

30

Standard shipping

May

1

Expedited shipping

May

2

Rush shipping

Everything else

May

1

Standard shipping

May

2

Expedited shipping

May

4

Rush shipping

50% off additional pages or up to 45% off*
Code: YAYPAGES | Ends 4/28!
Show
0 photos selected
These photos will be added to your project automatically.